July 1, 2009 9:39 pm

The Surf Lodge: Creature Comforts, Crispy Fries

As I have ventured to various restaurants both domestic and abroad, I have come to the realization that while food is one of the most charming aspects of a dining experience, it's the attitude of the wait staff that ultimately makes or breaks a meal out. We've all experienced attitude from the cranky waitress who would rather grill you with another nasty look than grill your steak to the temperature you've so kindly asked for. What it all comes down to is comfort level. If you're out to dinner at an upscale restaurant, you deserve your meal the way you've asked for —and with a smile.

The Surf Lodge, located in Montauk, New York, is the gold standard in dining and service. Located just a few minutes outside of town, the white lodge located on the bay, is quaint and lovely. The staff is welcoming and offers you cozy couches where you may enjoy a beer and relax before you've sat down to eat. The lodge reminds me of a mellow South Beach, a place where there is no judgment or dress code, any outfit will do. I would know because with the chilly temperature and my Miami blood, I graced the lodge in grey sweatpants, a plaid button down and an oversized tan coat. Part owner of the lodge, Jayma Cardosa smiled and clapped, "I love it! It's all about being comfortable."

Comfortable I was, as I sat at a table with friends overlooking the bay and was greeted by a friendly server, Raphael, who just happened to be from my hometown. He served a fresh summer salad, with a mixture of greens, topped with a light vinaigrette dressing. Moving on to the main course, a succulent Argentinean Steak with Chimichurri sauce that only intensified the flavor of the meal. I must confess, I also ordered a side of fries. But these weren't any ordinary greasy, guilt-filled, head for the Pepto-Bismol bottle fries. These were light and crispy, the kind you might find at a French or Belgian bistro. Our waters were refilled without question and our appetites were satiated leaving no room for dessert. I guess I'll just have to make my way back to the Surf Lodge for a little rest and relaxation next week, I just can't get enough.

—Nicole Segall

The Surf Lodge
183 Edgemere Street
Montauk, NY 11954
631.668.3284

— Written by Nicole Segall

< PREVIOUS ENTRY NEXT ENTRY >

Share This >

Login to comment